Friday, March 24, 2017

MESA GRANDE Indian Dave Toler to Discuss His Book on San Pasqual Tribe, Stolen by WHITES

San Pasqual Reservation tribal council member and longtime Valley Center resident David Toler, Jr.  who, according to records is of Mexican Indian descent whose descendants are listed on Mesa Grande rolls, discusses his book on San Pasqual, the land his ancestors stole.

He will have a book signing and make a presentation on his new book “Blood of the Band: An Ipai Family Story” Saturday, 11 a.m.¬–1 p.m. at the San Diego Archaeological Center located at 16666 San Pasqual Valley Road, Escondido. NO word if this will be in the FICTION SECTION...

The Ipai (also known as Kumeyaay) are the native people of northern San Diego County. This book illustrates how one Ipai family’s remarkable story forms part of the little-known, yet profoundly significant long-term history of human habitation in the land that only recently has come to be known as Southern California.

Beginning with the ancestors’ accounts of the creation of the world that link the Ipai with the unique characteristics of our region’s natural world, the journey then takes readers through the archaeological, historical, ethnographic and contemporary accounts of the dramatic transformations through which the Ipai have persisted and ultimately prospered.

Author David L. Toler, Jr. is an Ipai descendant of the La Chappa, Guachena and Nejo clans that once inhabited the San Pasqual Valley and the surrounding lands from ocean to mountains and deserts. Toler has long been an avid enthusiast of the culture and history of his people, a supporter of traditional cultural revitalization activities throughout the region, and an explorer who seeks out the ancient routes of his ancestors. Toler has served for many years as a member of the Tribal Council of the San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians.

The Jose Juan descendants have a different take on his "history".

Between Leonard Hill, Pacific Regional Director, Sacramento,  and Robert Bennett, Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Washington, D.C., by SECRETARIAL DECISION, the BIA completely disregards the enrollment statute.  

While page 2 of the 1966 Base Roll is a certification by Leonard Hill states that the San Pasqual enrollment applications have been approved in accordance with 25 CFR part 48, he goes on to state, "I further certify that the degree of SP Indian blood, as shown on the attached roll, has been computed in accordance with a Secretarial decision interpreting 'blood of the Band' to be total Indian blood of a person named on the basic membership Census Roll dated June 30, 1910."    

So, by 'secretarial decision' and a BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY, the BIA totally changed and undermined the SP Enrollment Statute . .  and it was used to enroll the Trask's and the Orosco's. 

Thursday, March 23, 2017


The Nooksack Tribe has been informed that ANY actions taken subsequent to their illegal (Nooksack Constitution) election, would not be recognized by the Bureau of Indian Affairs.  Yet, their "jihad" against the Nooksack 306 KNOWS NO BOUNDS!

Not to be stopped, they are issuing EVICTIONS of their ELDERLY members, WHO HAVE NOT BEEN disenrolled.  KATRICE ROMERO, you are a pig.

IS a violent response needed?   Or is the legal remedy still the correct one?

CONGRESS must Take Another LOOK at the INDIAN CIVIL RIGHTS ACT: Harold Monteau

We've posted articles before by attorney Harold Monteau .  Here's an article from Indian Country Today...we have been calling for this for over a decade. Maybe......this time?

Harold Monteau a citizen of the Chippewa Cree Tribe, calls on Congress to take another look at the Indian Civil Rights Act to address abuse, corruption and disenrollment among tribal governments:

The U.S. Congress may have to, and maybe should, revisit the Indian Civil Rights Act of 1968 (ICRA) considering the abrogative behavior of tribal governments, as of late, towards their own people regarding the Civil Rights of individual Indians, and in light of the corruption being exposed by numerous U.S. Attorney prosecutions.

The lack of such rights and the use (abuse?) of the defense of Sovereign Immunity by tribal governments has become a shield to sometimes illegal activities within tribal government and as a shield when committing egregious acts against the tribe’s own people. This is especially true regarding the recent use of mass disenrollment by tribal governments to enlarge shares of “per capita” payments from Indian Gaming Revenue or to put one faction of the tribe into perpetual power. In some cases, there is an element of fraud when re-recognized or newly recognized tribes use various rolls (or descendants from those rolls} to justify Federal Recognition by the U.S. Administrative (BIA) Congressional and Judicial Branches and later disavow those enrollees.

In any other context, that would be looked at as fraud upon the U.S. Government. Tribes, tribal attorneys and some legal scholars have misconstrued Supreme Court decisions to give tribal governments unfettered “plenary” power over membership decisions while providing no remedies for tribal members harmed by these decisions. Due process is literally non-existent or, at best, illusory, when any appeal is limited to the body that made the harmful decision in the first instance, or limited to a judiciary controlled by that body.

But, the U.S. Trustee stands idly by while the tribes, in the capacity of surrogate U.S. policy enforcers, continue to engage in what amounts to civil rights and human rights violations. Tribes are enforcing a U.S. policy, about blood quantum based tribal enrollment, and arbitrary termination of tribal membership, that has its origins in the allotment and termination era when the U.S. Indian Policy was to “disappear” all Indians into the mainstream. The trustee sits idly by while tribes engage in self-termination by arbitrary disenrollment of the trustee’s beneficiaries which serves the interests of the trustee in lessening its responsibilities and eventually eliminating its responsibilities towards Native Americans. Federal law and Federal Courts do not recognize any remedies for disenrolled Indians. In fact, the trustee seems more than happy to stop access to federal benefits for disenrolled Indians.

Wednesday, March 22, 2017

AFTER 10,000 Native Americans Lose THEIR Citizenship, DOJ Seeks TO STRIP it's FIRST...FROM A TERRORIST

My friend JAZZ SHAW has a post up on , about the Department of Justice seeking to strip citizenship from a TERRORIST!  This is what you have to do to get your citizenship REVOKED.   NOT SO in Native America...

Jazz points out:

You can’t take away the citizenship of a natural born American citizen, but we have revoked that status for naturalized citizens in the past, including Nazis who were discovered living here after having fled Europe following World War II.

As I wrote here:

We are talking about treason or overthrowing the government as a serious offense. No disenrollees have threatened overthrow of their tribal government. No bearing arms against tribal councils. In Indian Country, you can lose your citizenship for simply disagreeing with the tribal council. Putting a “wrong” member on the council or speaking your mind about their business entities can get one stripped of their citizenship.

How many American’s have been stripped of their citizenship, can you name ONE? Did Christopher Boyce, who sold secrets to the Russians, or Robert Hannssen?  NO.  Has Charles Manson lost his citizenship? No. How about American terrorists who advocate death to American and sharia law? Nope, uh-uh, but in Indian Country, the number is in the THOUSANDS. We have tribes like Snoqualmie in Washington, that have stripped citizenship simply for taking a position opposite of the tribal council.


Tuesday, March 21, 2017


Some Nooksack friends are sharing this on their FACEBOOK PAGES:

People of Nooksack 

For your information, the Nooksack Tribe currently has NO COUNCIL! They need a quorum of 5. There was no election held on March 19th, 2016.. 

Therefore their positions are NULL and VOID Lona Johnson's term is up Katherine Canete's position is up! Abby Smith's position is up! And Rick George--vice chairman's position is up. 

They cannot extend their positions according to the Constitution..They do not have the Constitutional power to extend their Rule.. They cannot Rule by Marshall Law! Please Share!

KGMI is reporting:

The federal government may have to take over the Nooksack tribe.

The tribe kicked out nearly 300 people, but did it without a duly elected tribal council, so the feds don’t recognize the dis-enrollments.

David Wilkins, a professor of American Indian Studies at the University of Minnesota tracks tribal dis-enrollments.

“This may well be the strongest case where the federal government has finally stepped in, to finally stand up for the rights of those individuals facing dis-enrollment,” says Wilkins.

KUOW reports the federal government sent letters to the tribe, saying if the council doesn’t hold a fair election, it could come in and take control of tribal services.

Wilkins says a wave of dis-enrollments followed the rise of tribal casinos in the 1990s.

Dr. David Wilkins New Book DISMEMBERED is Available on AMAZON and GOOGLE: Disenrollment Analysis Please Buy and Read

Our friend Dr. David Wilkins has his book DISMEMBERED out for sale.

While the number of federally recognized Native nations in the United States are increasing, the population figures for existing tribal nations are declining. This depopulation is not being perpetrated by the federal government, but by Native governments that are banishing, denying, or disenrolling Native citizens at an unprecedented rate. Since the 1990s, tribal belonging has become more of a privilege than a sacred right. Political and legal dismemberment has become a national phenomenon with nearly eighty Native nations, in at least twenty states, terminating the rights of indigenous citizens.

I was THRILLED to be mentioned in the acknowledgements, along with our friends Cathy Cory of Chukchansi and Mark and Carla Maslin, who is from the Redding Rancheria.  And Gene and Alice Langton-Sloan, who are subject of a post from this morning are also included.

After LAYING with the DOGS of CHUKCHANSI, Osceola Blackwood Ivory Group Sues for FLEAS?

Oh my, how could anyone have known that an unscrupulous tribal entity of an unscrupulous tribe, the Picayune Rancheria of Chukchansi Indians would breach a contract?  Say it out loud: $20 MILLION DOLLARS

See the filing here:    OBIG v. Chukchansi      I believe had this group done their due diligence, by simply reading Original Pechanga...they would have KNOWN they couldn't be trusted, right?


Picayune Rancheria of Chukchansi Indians
Picayune Rancheria
Chukchansi thuggery
Nancy Ayala
Chukchansi disenrollment

Gene Sloan, Disenrolled from Cahto Tribe of the Laytonville Rancheria HONORED for Protecting the Tribal Cultural Ways of the ENVIRONMENT

Our friend Alice Sloan was proud to inform us that her hubby Gene Sloan, who was first disenrolled over 22years ago from Cahto Tribe of the Laytonville Rancheria, then reinstated, and then tossed again from a 9th Circuit decision... was honored for his work in sharing his tribal cultural knowledge as you can see in his award here from the InterTribal Sinkyone Wilderness Council

Image may contain: text

Congratulations Gene, on protecting our world and on practicing the ways of our ancestors, even if your tribe shames itself in its treatment of you.

Gene Sloan speaking in
Sacramento in 2005
against Disenrollment

Learn More on Disenrollment, Ethnic Cleansing in Indian Gaming Country at these Links:

Thursday, March 16, 2017

Dr. Lehman Brightman, Founder of UNITED NATIVE AMERICANS Needs HELP and Prayers.

Our friend Quanah Parker Brightman is asking for prayers of healing and strength for his father, UNA founder Lehman Brightman.  He's recovering from Septic shock and is at Walnut Creek Kaiser.    Help a Native Warrior.
Financial help with recovery and housing assistance can be donated at their GOFUNDME page    Dr. Brightman FOUGHT for Native Rights....can we do the same for him?

Quanah Parker Brightman, father
Dr. Lehman Brightman
Lehman L. Brightman is a Sioux and Creek Indian who was born on the Cheyenne River Sioux Reservation in South Dakota. Professor Brightman is the founder and National President of United Native Americans, Inc. an Indian organization formed in 1968, to promote the progress and general welfare of American Indians. In his capacity as President of UNA, Mr. Brightman has testified in two U.S Senate Hearings on the deplorable conditions of Indian boarding schools and hospitals on reservations. He led investigations of seven Indian boarding schools and three Indian hospitals due to the poor service and abusive treatment of Indian people. He is a former football and track star at Oklahoma State University where he earned a B.A. degree, and he has an M.A. degree from the University of California at Berkeley. 

Mr. Brightman is an ex-Marine and served one year in the Korean conflict where he was wounded in action. Professor Brightman established and coordinated the first Native American Studies Program in the United States at UC Berkeley in 1969, and has since taught at the University of California in San Diego, Sacramento State University, D-Q University, and Contra Costa College in San Pablo, California.   Brightman is the author of numerous articles on the history of Indian education and federal boarding schools. 

He is the former editor of the first International Indian newspaper called Warpath, and was involved in the occupation of Alcatraz, and the takeover of Wounded Knee, and led the takeover and occupation of Mt. Rushmore in South Dakota in 1970. He was one of the national coordinators of the Longest Walk in 1978, and the Long Walk for Survival in 1980. At the present time, Mr. Brightman is writing a book on the history of the Indian Civil Rights Movement from the 1960's to the present.

Wednesday, March 15, 2017

Native America Calling: Disenrollment and Re-Enrollment Show 3/15 SHOW EMBEDDED

Native America Calling is doing it's annual show on Disenrollment on 3/15 at 10 am PDT.   This years episode includes Robinson Rancheria Chairman Eddie Crandell, who brought back members who were disenrolled under the late Tracy Avila.  The restoration of the tribe's honor is good for Indian Country.


Call in:   1-800-996-2848

The Robinson Rancheria of Pomo Indians granted tribal membership back to 60 people who were disenrolled nine years ago. The action is a departure from a recent wave of disenrollement among some tribes in the west. 

Disenrolled members are no longer federally recognized tribal citizens and as a result lose benefits like health care, percap income and even housing. The Nooksack Indian Tribe is suing the federal government over sanctions imposed over election disputes stemming from disenrollment. 

Sovereignty gives independent tribal nations the ability to determine their members. But campaigns against disenrollment are aiming to change opinions on this perfectly legal act. Is mass disenrollment an idea whose time has come?


9th Circuit RULES AGAINST Former UNITED AUBURN chairwoman

The Sacramento Bee has the story of the 9th Circuit again failing to provide justice for aggrieved Indians under the Indian Civil Rights Act

A federal appeals court Tuesday rejected a challenge by former United Auburn tribal chairwoman Jessica Tavares and other dissident members who charged they were illegally banished and denied their shares of profits from the lucrative Thunder Valley Casino near Lincoln.
The ruling by the United States 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, responding to a bitter 2013 clash in one of California’s wealthiest casino tribes and ensuing litigation, effectively rejected claims that the tribe “imposed unlawful restraints” on the “liberty” of Tavares and three other members by cutting off their income and banning them from United Auburn properties.

Pechanga Native Kent Appel, Native Songwriter/Poet's SONG on Disenrollment: A Paper Genocide (Lament of the Disenrolled Indian)

My cousin, Kent Appel, who contributes greatly to the comment section here, as 'AAMOKAT' is also a songwriter and poet.  His song on Disenrollment NAILS IT

"Casino people, Shameful Tribe, Betrayed Your Own, A Paper Genocide."








With the Robinson Rancheria restoring their disenrolled last month and Enterprise last year, and Grand Ronde disenrolled triumphant in court...there is HOPE that tribal nations who disenroll, will do the right thing.

Monday, March 13, 2017

Guy Who Worked With Tribe that Abused Their OWN PEOPLE, Wants Transparency for Others UPDATE: Schmit responds

The author of this hit piece Charles Banks-Altekruse promoted the North Fork Rancheria's attempt at off reservation gaming, and also did work for the Robinson Rancheria a disenroller until recently.  He  reportedly did work for the ENTERPRISE RANCHERIA, WHILE it was disenrolling and abusing their members, now, he wants transparency for Stand Up's Cheryl Schmit  We have asked for comment from Schmit, but have not had a response as yet.

AND her response:
This public relations person (who also represents North Fork and Enterprise both seeking off reservation casinos)  obviously hired by the Tribe and Boyd Gaming is attempting to change the narrative.   The issue is the citizens of Elk Grove were not provided an open, fair or transparent process by the Bureau of Indian Affairs or the City Officials of Elk Grove.  
Moreover, the Regional Director Dutschke is involved in the decision-making in this case. The Regional Director, shares extensive family ties with members of the Wilton Rancheria. These ties present a clear conflict of interest. The Record of Decision was signed by Larry Roberts who lacked the authority to sign as a Principal Deputy Secretary and Michael Black lacked the authority to take land into trust.  There must be a thorough review by the IBIA.  Otherwise,  any decision to take land into trust will be inherently tainted and subject to investigation.

The Elk Grove City Council was correct in asking hard questions of Cheryl Schmit, the director of Stand Up for California!, regarding her intervention in the proposed Wilton Rancheria casino project.

People deserve to know whether this self-proclaimed ‘statewide gaming watchdog’ is indeed independent of conflicts of interest – or merely a ‘guard dog’ for established casino tribes and card rooms, as many suspect.

Lyle Davis: Disenrollment and Tribal Abuses and Solutions from an Outside Perspective

Friend and Editor of the Escondido weekly THE PAPER , Lyle Davis has some thought on what he's researched during the recent 3 months.  Feel free to comment and share.  Some of my comments are in blue
Lyle Davis Editor

Having just completed a two-part series on disenrollment as it affects both the San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians and the Pechanga Band of Luiseno Indians, I've become aware that this problem is not limited to just these two bands and their respective casinos but is simply a microcosm of what is happening statewide and nationwide.

I'm also aware that, because of sovereignty issues, the various tribes have little, if any, oversight on their distribution of revenues received from the casinos and the manipulation of these funds and/or disenrollment can and does have a major impact on tribal members.

There are frequent allegations of abuses, from skimming profits to using the casino revenue as a personal bank account, to settling political scores, to enhancing one's own personal income by disenrolling someone else. None of which allegations can be addressed by district attorneys or attorneys general at either the state or federal level, all because of the sovereignty issue.

The only solution, it appears to me, is to band together as one united Indian nation, elect some charismatic leaders who can motivate your members and then go on the warpath. No pun intended. This group, once formed, needs to descend on the offices at the county, state and federal level and raise hell - on a regular basis, demanding congressional legislation that opens up the books and requires accountability.  (OP: Lyle raises a good point in this clutters. On having a leader/leaders who will stand up.  The difference to me, is: I AM PECHANGA, my great great grandmother's LEGACY to ALL her descendants. I'm not going to be someone ELSE.  Also, as far as the Congress is concerned, it IS settled, the compacts were approved, without them caring about open books)

There is an incentive for state and federal governments to get involved . . . and it's financial. A greater percentage of casino revenues would flow into government coffers .. . and, given the multi-billion dollar industry the casinos represent, the amount would be meaningful. (OP:  I think it's past time that CA opens up gaming, government run)

Pressure needs to be regular and steady . . . peaceful . . but firm. You need to camp out on the doorstep of Assembly members, senate members, congressional offices, governors, bureaus, the Bureau of Indian Affairs . . . any governmental office that has any degree of influence over tribal affairs need to subjected to constant pressure. (Come election time . . . these candidates need to know there are votes and financial support available for those who offer sincere support. [Realize,however, that the casino treasury is overflowing with money for campaign contributions and regular paid lobbyists already on staff . . . so it's an uphill battle] - realistic proposals for new congressional legislation, at both the federal and state levels, need to be developed, proposed, promoted, and demanded.    (OP: Agreed, yet, trying to get those who are aggrieved, to even send an email is mostly unsuccessful)

Then, and only then, will the Indian Nations succeed in getting a fair shake. Good luck. Go to work! Make it happen!

Mark Macarro Called OUT for Destroying 8 Pechanga Generations #StopDisenrollment

Here are young descendants of Paulina Hunter, ages 5 thru 9 years, disenrolled from Pechanga 107 years after her death  They are the 8th generation of Pechanga people that are traceable.
Paulina Hunter Descendants
8th generation stripped of their heritage prior to birth by Mark Macarro

The children are the  REAL faces of those harmed by their own people, in this advocacy movement and in some cases, their OWN FAMILIES.
Been seeing a lot of pictures of Natives against Tribal Disenrollment, HAVE YOU posted?

Mark Macarro of Pechanga got rid of 25% of his tribe, including elders, and children and the UNBORN.  Additionally, he's kept his own COUSINS from their rightful place in the tribe.

Sunday, March 12, 2017

Bureau of Indian Affairs Pulling OKEY DOKE on FOIA Requests Says Researcher Emilio Reyes

Friend to this blog, and MANY Native Americans looking for information on their ancestry, EMILIO REYES is reporting

For over 5 years I've done extensive research on the archives of the Bureau of Indian Affairs. From the National Archives to public libraries, to online collections, to BIA Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests.

After discovering Non-Natives have occupied the San Pasqual reservation since 1909 and exposing historical errors to the Office of the DOI, Secretary of the Interior, the BIA has refused to be compliant under 43 CFR. The California BIA Regional FOIA coordinator, Douglas Garcia, has made almost imposible to complete any of my FOIA requests.
Emilio Reyes

From claiming fee waivers "do not" meet the required guidelines, to "forgetting" to process requests in a timely manner, to claiming such records don't exist even though I have copies of the original records, to redacting information even when death records are being provided, which will not compromise any information under the Privacy Act.

Furthermore, at least 15 FOIA appeals are sitting in the Office of the Solicitor's office unresponded.
If you've experienced a similar problem with BIA or have a concern regarding FOIA requests that have been submitted to any agency within the Department of the Interior, He'd be interested to know, you can leave your information in  the comments.  Emilio will be escalating his appeals in the court level and will be working with a local senator to request an investigation, an internal audit of BIA records, and possibly changes and/or amendments on FOIA guidelines.

Maybe the new Secretary of the Interior, will take a look at the okey doke, the shuffling of papers while claiming they can't find anything...will end.

Saturday, March 11, 2017

When 1/3 of the 9th Circuit Got it RIGHT:Jeffredo v. Macarro Dissenting Opinion, Smacks Down Majority Decision

The 9th Circuit was wrong on the Trump Executive Orders, but in 2010, ONE of the Justices got it ABSOLUTELY correct, and the DISSENT was published, which was unusual.

In a previous post U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals Rejects... we wrote that it was rare to have the dissenting opinion published. Well, we have that for you here. We have bolded many of the pertinent portions where the dissenting judge points out the obvious to those justices that apparently took the "blind" portion of the justice is blind too seriously. Take a look.

Money Quote1: "Here, appellants are not directly challenging the merits of their disenrollment, i.e., whether they are direct descendants from the original Pechanga Temecula people," Wilkens wrote. "Rather, appellants challenge under the (Indian Civil Rights Act) the manner of their disenrollment. The former would be barred by tribal sovereign immunity, whereas the latter is not."

Money Quote2: The combination of the current and potential restrictions placed upon Appellants and the loss of their life-long Pechanga citizenship constitutes a severe restraint on their liberty
.The majority analyzes each of these grounds separately, instead of collectively
, and determines that none amounts to a detention.
I respectfully disagree with this approach

Dissenting Opinion Jeffredo v Macarro

Thursday, March 9, 2017

Tribal Disenrollment Discussion on Friday 3/10

I'm excited to be invited to spend an hour or so with Michael Kickingbear and David Greyowl, hosts of NATIVE OPINION radio show March 10th at 9:30 EST.   Hope you will both listen and join in.

Imagine for a moment the home that you grew up in. The neighborhood and the town that you spent your childhood. How familiar it feels to you. The friends you made, maybe other family members that you spent time with regularly. That safe and secure feeling of familiarity.
Now imagine one day that you are told that you may no longer live in your home and that in fact, you no longer have a right to stay in it, or the right to even live in your neighborhood. Imagine how you would feel if you suddenly were faced with having to move away from that home, those surroundings...all because someone (else) said you are no longer welcome.  That you are no longer allowed to even stay in your neighborhood. How would you feel
We will be discussing of course, my family's disenrollment, but also how a moratorium on membership affected more than just one family.

I'd like to get into the issues of the BIA and how they are complicit, involved and sometimes TO BLAME for what's going on, especially in CA.

PLEASE, visit their webpage,  share the news with your family and let's get INVOLVED.

Wednesday, March 8, 2017

THE PAPER, Escondido Weekly THE DISAPPEARING INDIAN EXPOSE Part II The Pechanga Band of Casino Indians and Tribal Disenrollment

Lyle Davis, editor of the Escondido weekly, known as THE PAPER takes a LONG look at the enormous amount of money generated by Tribal casinos and the revenue stream that goes to the enrolled tribal members of the   Pechanga Band of Casino Indians.  Included the often harsh impact of "tribal disenrollment," all in this week's issue.

You can read his first article on San Pasqual Band, which runs the VALLEY VIEW CASINO.

The Right of Tribal Sovereignty Allows Abuse of Indians, But Sovereign ABUSE is NOT RIGHT

South Africa had the SOVEREIGN RIGHT to impose APARTHEID on their Black Citizens.  Did that make it RIGHT?   No?  

Words to live by for honorable tribes

Why does nobody care when tribes like my own, Pechanga, do it on their reservation?  The ACLU doesn't care about our civil liberties, NARF could care less about our Native American Rights, and the Justice Department doesn't give a hoot about justice.

Tribal gaming has helped many tribes in CA, come out of poverty, Pechanga included.

Unfortunately, with success, greed soon follows. Instead of helping all their people, including those they placed in a moratorium hold, who rightfully belonged to the tribe they looked at who they could get rid of to increase their per capita. The money hasn't made everyone happy.

The facts are clear, most tribes have not treated their people as abominably as Pechanga, Pala, Redding Rancheria, Picayune Rancheria, Nooksack and others have treated their people. It's more like Tribal Terrorism on the aforementioned tribal reservations.

I posted this in 2007 a great article that still applies:

Reconciling MORAL OUTRAGE at Pechanga Tribe with Self Determination

Here are excerpts from an excellent article by Sheryl Lightfoot about how to support sovereignty issues, while not supporting the actions when they are morally repugnant, such as Pechanga's disenrollment of 25% of their tribe in order to enrich the remaining members.

In order to be sovereign nations, we must act like sovereign nations. But that does not mean that in order to support self-determination in principle, we need to agree with every decision of other sovereign nations.

...The executives of our indigenous nations have the right, if not the moral responsibility, to send letters and make phone calls of complaint directly to the executives of the Cherokee Nation, expressing their concern over the (Cherokee Freedmen) disenrollment decision. This can be done while supporting the inherent right of an indigenous nation to determine its own membership.

Another tactic which can be employed by other indigenous nations or the private citizens of other nations is the art of moral persuasion, or ''moral suasion,'' as it has also been termed. This involves a campaign of exposure and embarrassment. (OP: This is what we've been pursuring for 8 years now)  OP: Now, tribes like Pechanga practice APARTHEID on their reservations.

OP: My view is this

Tribal sovereignty is something that should be nurtured and cherished.  The question was asked, "what could be done?".

Frankly, economic sanctions of another tribal nation, plus public embarrassment may be the only course of action that is effective. For instance, in South Africa, it was their SOVEREIGN RIGHT as a free nation to impose apartheid on their country.

What recourse did civilized countries use to bring down this hateful policy? Economic sanctions and world ridicule of the policy. No trade, no travel, no money. Final result, end of apartheid and a welcome back to South Africa into the world community.
Similarly, citizens of the United States (OP: AND California especially) can impose their own economic sanctions on the Tribal Nations of Pechanga, Pala,  by boycotting their nation's business

Stop patronizing their casinos, hotel, restaurants and their powwows. Let them know that we do not agree with their system of denying civil rights to their people and until they follow their own tribal law, citizens of our country will NOT support their nation, but will patronize (OP: In other words, support tribal gaming elsewhere) their competitor nations.

Also, letting state and federal representatives know that we expect them not to support a nation that would treat its citizens this way, especially NOT to allow them increased monetary benefits by expanding their casino slot machines.

Readers, there are 250 members of the band that were disenrolled and 200 people who are caught in Pechanga's illegal moratorium (illegal in that SOVEREIGN nation, against the sovereign nation of Pechanga's own constitution) Pechanga and its chairman, Mark Macarro deserves no benefit from violations of their laws and against citizens of the United States. Chukchansi has exterminated 60% of it's tribe, Redding 25%. Elders and children abused by unconstitutional acts under the BIA's eyes, with NO SANCTIONS.

Please ask your friends to read our blog and share it on social media and friends, please let me know your opinion by posting comments.

Reworked and Re-posted from 2007

TOP TEN INDIAN CASINOS To AVOID Like the PLAGUE: IF they will CHEAT Their OWN People, WHY NOT Their Customers

These Ten Casinos are some we chose to STAY AWAY from and NOT spend your entertainment dollars there.   They are in NO particular order, except for Pechanga..well, because they are MY TRIBE and they cheated MY family and dishonored MY ancestors.

There is much more detail at each of the links, please click through
The comments are OPEN...if you have OTHER candidates for avoidance, and them there.

PECHANGA RESORT & CASINO:  Pechanga Band of Luiseno Indians CA

In 2004, 130+ adult members and their immediate families were disenrolled from the Pechanga Band. The members were all descendants of Chief Pablo Apish, a historically significant leader of the Pechanga/Temecula people. None of the members were allowed to participate in the 2004 tribal elections as a result of their disenrollment.

An additional extended family of approximately 100 adults was disenrolled in March 2006 when tribal officials determined that the ancestor from whom they are lineally descended from was not an Original Pechanga/Temecula person. This determination was made despite the fact that a report prepared by a well known anthropologist hired by the Band's Enrollment Committee concluded she was a Pechanga/Temecula person. 

The most recent disenrollment of 100+ adults and children was especially egregious as the General Membership, the Tribe's governing body, had previously passed a law which (1) repealed the Tribe's disenrollment procedures and (2) made it illegal for the Enrollment Committee to disenroll members.
There is ALSO a moratorium on membership, which also keeps Chairman Mark Macarro's OWN COUSIN out as well as family of other members...equal opportunity OFFENDER?

VALLEY VIEW CASINO:  San Pasqual Band of Diegueno Indians CA

Run by NON San Pasqual blood, this tribe has worked to both DISENROLL members, and KEEP approximately 125 TRUE San Pasqual descendants OUT OF THE TRIBE.  Tip:  Iron Eyes Cody, played an Indian, but he was NOT.  Many of the San San Pasqual, but they are NOT.

Northwood Casino - Nooksack Tribal Nation WA

This tribe has been working for YEARS to disenroll a family that has been proven to belong.  306 people are suffering at the hand of a tribal chairman, Bob Kelly, who was adopted into the tribe!   Jobs lost, benefits stolen, families' abused and they change the rules in midstream, even to the point of denying children.  They might force you to hit a 17 at the casino?

Turning Stone Resort Casino  - Oneida Nation, NY

Ray Halbritter has gained fame with the anti Redskins mascot issue, but has clearly not been known for stripping his aunt Maisie Shenandoah  and three dozen tribal members “of their voice” in Nation affairs — meaning they were not eligible for Nation programs and services.  To prove it...he simply BULLDOZED his own family's HOMES...

PALA RESORT & CASINO:   Pala Band of Luiseno Indians  CA

Corrupt leader Robert Smith has terminated the citizenship of 154 tribal members, threatened numerous others with a similar fate.  The General Council has no access to the business records.  Evictions, stripping of rights, Elder Abuse, Child name it...
Dare we Use the Word?

RED HAWK CASINO:Shingle Springs Rancheria CA

On January 7, 2014, the Cook Family received the devastating news they were being suspended as members of the Shingle Springs Band of Miwok Indians recommended by the Enrollment Committee and enacted by the Tribal Council.  A total of 138 family members were being questioned of their lineal heritage to their ancestors who were named on a BIA Census.  On March 7, 2014 the Cook Family were disenrolled from the Tribe and stripped of their rights and citizenship

CHUKCHANSI GOLD CASINO:  Picayune Rancheria of Chukchansi Indians CA


Are you close to Tucson?  If so, you should attend this.

The “Who Belongs? From Tribal Kinship to Native Nation Citizenship to Disenrollment” Conference will be held at the James E. Rogers College of Law, University of Arizona, March 9-10, 2017.


This first-of-its-kind conference will bring together prominent scholars in the field of Federal Indian Law, International Law, and American Indian Studies, as well as tribal government officials, to discuss recent trends in Indian Country dealing with citizenship and community belonging, including disenrollment.

“The conference is designed to address the sensitive issues surrounding who has a hereditary and/or cultural right to be a part of a Native and Aboriginal community, and what are an individual’s responsibilities to that community,” said conference organizer Professor Robert Hershey. “It is our hope that an atmosphere of respect, understanding, listening, and learning will be fostered, and that our gathering will promote utmost dignity.”

Confirmed participants include thought-leaders
Stephen Cornell, Matthew Fletcher (Grand Traverse Band of Ottawa & Chippewa Indians), Norbert Hill (Oneida Nation of Wisconsin), Joseph Kalt, Richard Luarkie (Pueblo of Laguna), Pamela Palmater (Mi’kmaq), Patricia Riggs (Ysleta del Sur Pueblo), Lorinda Riley (Cherokee/Native Hawaiian), Wenona Singel (Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians), Kevin Washburn (Chickasaw Nation of Oklahoma), David Wilkins (Lumbee),

Additionally, as highlighted last month by the New York Times, disenrollment has reached an epidemic level, with as many as 9,000 Native Americans having been jettisoned from nearly 80 tribes in recent years. As Professor Robert A. Williams, Jr. (Lumbee) recently stated in the New York Times, “It’s almost become an industry in some parts of Indian Country.”

The conference is designed for attendance by tribal leaders and citizens, tribal and federal government officials, attorneys and advocates practicing Native American and Indigenous Peoples law, Native and Indigenous people, officers of tribal enrollment and constitution reform committees, and faculty and students of American Indian Studies and law.

Monday, March 6, 2017


This despite the fact the Bureau has known for decades, the BIA wrongfully enrolled hundreds of Non-San Pasqual Indians in the Tribe and whose families have conspired with the BIA to keep the True San Pasqual Indians from enrollment in their Tribe, and from Federal Recognition .

I have the the complaint HERE (START AT PAGE 13)

How can Bureau of Indian Affairs defend their defense of non-San Pasqual Indians, versus their defense of non-San Pasqual Indians?  It makes NO sense!  
If you think the OROVILLE DAM break would be a disaster, think what is coming up for California's Bureau of Indian Affairs, headed by Amy (her again?) Dutschke. The implications of what the B.I.A.  has done at San Pasqual is STUNNING.  There is a lawsuit outstanding now for $89 million the last I heard.   Is the Sacramento Office of Bureau of Indian Affairs going to attempt to defend their fraud and conspiracy, against the enrollment of the True San Pasqual Indians?   How will Sacramento of Bureau of Indian Affairs, complicit in the corruption of THEFT of INDIAN HERITAGE of Jose Juan & Guadalupe Descendants, defend their enrollment of non-San -Pasqual Indians against the True San Pasqual Indians?

The matter of Jose Juan, wife Guadalupe and daughter Modesta Contreras, which we wrote about in April 2014 has reached the filing stage.  Our U.S. Attorneys will be defending the United States of America.  The documentary evidence we've seen is ...overwhelming.   Might they settle to save this from becoming COBELL in magnitude and costing taxpayers hundreds of millions??

Sunday, March 5, 2017

Santa Clara Pueblo vs. Martinez: Can Divergent Opinions Be Correct? Is The Decision only a Shield ..or..a Weapon?

I'm fortunate to be involved in a lot of email conversations.  Because on of ours went out to a large group, I got a couple of responses and I'd like you to see them.  As comment section is open.  Thank you to BOTH.

Here's the first, from a responder from the American Indian Resource Center of the County of Los Angeles Public Library

Santa Clara Pueblo vs. Martinez (1978) - the Supreme Court essentially ruled that tribal membership does NOT come under Federal Jurisdiction - ONLY the official tribal government has ultimate authority.  Legal challenges to that decision over the last 39 years have failed .  

Theoretically it is possible to over-rule that decision but it would take a major very public concerted public effort, like with DAPL, for the feds to even consider examining it.  (OP:  ARE we UP to this challenge?)

IMO as with many American Indian issues, the feds think they've already done their part, they avoid such issues as much as possible, and just let the tribes deal with it.

This of course, triggers a response from one of our friends/family from PALA.  It's lengthy and will continue after the jump:

Friday, March 3, 2017

THE VOICE of AMERICA on Disenrollment: Cecily Hilleary Reporting on the Destruction in Native America

WELCOME VOAnews readers!  Thank you for visiting and learning about tribal disenrollment.  Please, look around the side, the pictures on the left will take you to other stories.  And please, GOOGLE + and SHARE!_

The Voice of America, one of the largest news organizations in the WORLD, reports on the tribal disenrollment epidemic.   I am grateful to be quoted in the article.

“They have desecrated the memory of our ancestors,” Cuevas said. “The Pechanga tribal chairman has ripped our history from us, without evidence. And yet his ancestor, back in the day, called my ancestor ‘Aunt.’”

FUNNY, MACARRO will NEVER mention this. Nor the fact that he's keeping his OWN cousins out of the tribe......

Rick Cuevas, Original Pechanga Blogger with
his ancestor Paulina Hunter who was disenrolled
107 years after her death, by a corrupt Tribal Council
                                   (Photo: Iliana Cuevas)

Disenrollment is an epidemic in reservations across Indian country. Cuevas tracks these cases on his Original Pechanga website: So far, 11,000 Indians have been exiled from dozens of tribes. In one of the more extreme cases, tribal members living off California’s tiny Elem Pomo colony attempted to disenroll every Elem Pomo Indians living on the colony – among them, the last living speaker of the Elem Pomo language.


Wednesday, March 1, 2017

THE PAPER, Escondido Weekly Exposes The San Pasqual Band of Casino Indians and Tribal Disenrollment

Lyle Davis, editor of the Escondido weekly, known as THE PAPER takes a LONG look at the enormous amount of money generated by Tribal casinos and the revenue stream that goes to the enrolled tribal members of the San Pasqual Band of Casino Indians. And the often harsh impact of "tribal disenrollment," all in this week's issue.  As an added bonus, he's going to have a second issue on Pechanga

You can access it via THIS LINK, or read it below but and SHARE!

RYAN ZINKE Overwhelmingly Confirmed as Secretary of the Interior

Montana Rep. Ryan Zinke won Senate confirmation Wednesday as President Donald Trump's Interior secretary, giving him responsibility for overseeing the nation's 400 million acres of public land, mostly in the West.

The Republican-controlled Senate approved the nomination, 68-31 as 16 Democrats and one independent joined with 51 Republicans to support the choice. Several Democrats from Western states as well as those facing tough re-elections next year, including Montana's Jon Tester, Indiana's Joe Donnelly and Joe Manchin of West Virginia, voted for Zinke.

Sen. Maria Cantwell of Washington state, the top Democrat on the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, said she is not convinced that Zinke will be able to "stand up" to Trump and prevent oil, gas and mining companies from unduly exploiting public lands
Cantwell also said Zinke appears willing to support transfer of some federal lands to states, citing his vote for the GOP-sponsored rules package. She worries that Zinke may weaken or repeal recent designations by President Barack Obama of national monuments, including Utah's Bears Ears monument.