Monday, March 18, 2013

OPEN LETTER TO TRIBAL LEADERS: Tribes Fighting Hurts All Indians. She IGNORES Disenrollments.

Here is an open letter from the Chairperson of the NORTH FORK RANCHERIA, which has successfully reservation shopped to get an approval for a casino away from their reservation. She completely ignores the ravages that disenrollment and banishment takes on Indians.

The North Fork Rancheria of Mono Indians of California recently became only the sixth tribe in the past 25 years to successfully navigate the Secretarial “two-part” process for acquiring new land for tribal-government gaming.

Our Tribe, with over 1,950 tribal citizens, engaged in this rigorous and lengthy federal process because, like other Indian people nation-wide, we had been denied a land base or “functional” reservation from which to conduct economic development for the betterment of our people due to numerous historical injustices.

For over a decade we worked in a collaborative and transparent manner with local, state and federal officials to reclaim a small fraction of our historical land base.  Our project was assessed and approved by two gubernatorial administrations, two federal administra­tions, four Interior Secretaries, nine Assistant Secretaries, and multiple local jurisdictions.

We now have 305 acres of tribal land in Madera County in trust and our goal with this land is similar to the goals of other California tribes with trust land eligible for gaming. We seek to build a tribal-government gaming facility on sovereign land to provide economic self-sufficiency for our Tribe and citizens and generate business opportunities and investment in Madera County.

Our project, which is overwhelmingly supported by our local community, carries the added, and perhaps most important, benefit of being able to immediately generate thousands of local jobs in one of the most economically depressed regions of the state and nation.

The final remaining administrative step in this process is the State Legislature’s ratification of our State-Tribal Gaming Compact, which we negotiated with Governor Jerry Brown.  Similar to other recently ratified gaming compacts, our compact provides substantial payments to mitigate local impacts and funding for non-gaming tribes across the state while lessening local and state fiscal obligations. Paired with the Wiyot Tribe’s compact, our compact also avoids large-scale economic development in ecologically sensitive regions near the Sierra National Forest/Yosemite (North Fork) and Humboldt Bay National Wildlife Refuge (Wiyot).

Native American tribes – especially those, like us, without a functional land base -- face many obstacles in overcoming decades of poverty, political disenfranchisement, and loss of historical lands. Perhaps the most surprising barrier we face comes from tribes with established gaming facilities using their financial and political power to crush the social and economic aspirations of newcomer tribes like ours in order to protect their own self-interests.

Some of these tribes say they don’t want competition—or even the potential for as yet unforeseen competition. Others appear to be seeking political advantage for future negotiations with the state or other parties. Whatever the motivation, some tribes today seek to interfere with or derail other legitimate tribal gaming projects.  OP:  We wrote about that in Indian vs. Indian and Thuggish Chukchansi Tribe…

Claims by some tribal leaders that seek to restrict other tribes to the tiny, arbitrary, contemporary “reservation” lands that do not accurately reflect actual historical lands are especially disheartening and disappoining. The final determination to approve or reject a tribal gaming enterprise should be based on the facts and merits of each case and not on the fear of future potential competition or misrepresentations of a tribe’s process in pursuing opportunity for its people.

The North Fork Rancheria supports all tribes in their endeavors to restore and rebuild tribal legitimacy, cultures, resources, and lands. Through the years we have supported many tribes acquiring new land for gaming -- including some who now oppose us.
OP: Madame Chairperson, you have been STUNNINGLY quiet over the corruption happening to your closest neighbors by the tribal council at the Picayune Rancheria and we've never heard from you about what's going on in the south at Pechanga, Santa Ysable and Pala..
The destructive pattern of Tribe vs. Tribe, Indians fighting Indians must stop before it undermines all tribes, tribal citizens, tribal gaming, and tribal-sovereignty.

By fighting one another, we risk losing our Native ways and dignity -- our understanding and practice of true indigenous values, cultures, and principles. If we are not careful, we risk losing the one opportunity that has promised and delivered so much to Indian Country.

Native American tribal leaders today stand at an important crossroads: They can choose the path of tribal infighting and “divide and conquer” tactics that have historically devastated Indian Country. Or they can call upon the traditional values of Native people – respect, caring, and sharing – to ensure that the newfound gains from tribal gaming are enhanced and protected for generations of Native peoples.

Tribal leaders cannot trumpet “tribal sovereignty” publicly while betraying it in private conduct towards fellow tribes. OP, OR actions that HARM THEIR OWN PEOPLE.  We must resolve differences by engaging in respectful, professional tribal government-to-government consultation prior to taking public positions that undermine other sovereign nations.

It’s time for tribes to unite behind tribal sovereignty and solidarity. The proceeds from tribal gaming can do great good for all tribes if we stop fighting and start sharing.   NOT IF THEY STEAL PER CAPITA from rightful members via moratoriums and disenrollment

North Fork Rancheria of Mono Indians Elaine Bethel-Fink is Chairperson of the 1,950-tribal-citizen North Fork Rancheria of Mono Indians of California. She has served in that position for most of the past decade.


Anonymous said...

She only wants her share of the gaming money. Chukchansi wants to keep her tribe from getting some of their share.

Erick Rhoan said...

It was a smart move to not mention the disenrollments. First, it’s a divisive issue and touches upon one of the most sensitive areas of Indian law. Given that other large gaming tribes have disenrolled members and are currently taking heat for it, North Fork is wise not to stir the pot regarding these ongoing disputes. Which brings us to the second point (and touching the real purpose of this letter).

North Fork is officially introducing itself to other gaming tribes, tribes that do not want competition and have lobbied against North Fork’s casino efforts. However, with their land base secured (minus ongoing litigation against them, which I think will ultimately fail) and their plans ready to initiate, they are proceeding full steam ahead and want to join the community of Indian gaming nations. By acknowledging their opposition and calling for unity, they can delicately state that fighting them is going to be a waste of time and they should begin cooperating with each other. The last thing they need to mention is the disenrollments.

One hopes that Elaine Bethel-Fink’s appeal to tribal unity and Native ways do not include disenrolling members for not being “true” North Fork Indians. But do not look for clues here.

for ALL nations...for ALL chukchansi people said...

just about the only thing the three factions of "tribal government" at picayune--the ayala, lewis, and reid councils--agree upon is fighting tooth and nail against north fork EVER opening their gaming facility...table mountain joins them in the fight as many at picayune, and table mountain, have mono blood AND relations actually enrolled at north fork, it just goes to show once again that they have forgotten the indian way and HAVE NO honor...

i attended the hearing on the north fork casino proposal in madera in 2007 or 2008, listening to each and every tribal council member (past and present) from picyune AND table mountain stand up and speak against north fork establishing their casino...i finally had had enough when leann walker grant, tribal chair at table mountain, took the floor to bash north she walked by me to her seat, i said quite loudly "bring the people home to table mountain...AND picayune!" others near me, including picayune tribal council member harold hammond gave that a big smile...

i must say, to their credit, tribal council representatives from both tule river (eagle mountain casino) and santa rosa tachi (tachi palace casino) stood and gave positive testimony, WELCOMING north fork mono into their gaming future and supporting them in their venture...

i believe the testimony from that hearing, which lasted over four hours, is available on-line and makes for some very interesting reading...

Anonymous said...

Wyiot tribe is disenrolling their tribal members they started sending out notices this week you must now be 1/8 to be enrolled in the quilt tribe this tribe needs to be investigate it by bia head councilman is sing these letters when he himself is not 1/8 wyiot now can this happen and if your no longer a member of your tribe were do you turn you have no tribe